Oldtimers Championship
John “The Bird” Christmas Memorial Trophy
| 2022 | Eskasoni Eagles |
| 2019 | Sipekne'katik |
| 2018 | Eskasoni 3 |
| 2017 | Eskasoni |
| 2016 | Castle Bay |
| 2015 | Eskasoni |
| 2014 | Qamsipuk |
| 2013 | Membertou |
| 2005 | Eskasoni Eagles |
| 2004 | Eskasoni Thunder |
| 2003 | Waycobah |
| 2002 | Eskasoni |
| 2001 | Indian Brook |
| 2000 | Eskasoni Eagles |
| 1999 | Eskasoni |
| 1998 | Membertou and Eskasoni |